Wilson’s 64-yard completion to Micah Simon set up a game-tying field goal with one second left in regulation. BYU went on to beat Tennessee 29-26 in the second overtime session when Ty’Son Williams scored from 5 yards out with help from his offensive linemen.
“It’s one of those things where all your reads and all your decision-making and what kind of coverage they are in, it kind of all goes out the window,” said Wilson, who was sacked four times and pressured for most of the night. “It’s kind of like you know what, where can I extend the play?”
The remarkable rally enabled BYU to rebound from a 30-12 loss to No. 13 Utah and avoid its first 0-2 start since 1991.
“Oh, this is huge,” said BYU coach Kalani Sitake, whose team plays Southern California and No. 14 Washington the next two weeks. “We obviously looked at the schedule and we know games that we want to win and want to perform well. I don’t think our guys are proud of what they did last week, but we talk about getting over that feeling, and the best way to do it is play the next week and prepare for it.”
Instead, it’s Tennessee that is 0-2 for the first time since 1988, when the Vols lost their first six games. Tennessee has gone 6-16 over its past 22 games.
“I’ve been through worse here,” Vols offensive tackle Marcus Tatum said. “We’ve all been through worse here. We’ve seen worse, so it’s just look at the positive. We fought. We just need to continue to fight.”
Tennessee was trying to bounce back from a 38-30 season-opening loss to 26-point underdog Georgia State. For most of the night, it appeared the Vols would do just that.
They got 154 yards rushing from Ty Chandler and two touchdown catches from Jauan Jennings. They controlled both sides of the line of scrimmage pretty much the entire game.
Yet that ultimately wasn’t enough, thanks to that Wilson-to-Simon connection.
BYU was facing third-and-6 from its own 20 with less than 20 seconds left when Wilson threw deep to Simon, who got way behind cornerback Alontae Taylor and caught the pass just beyond midfield. Simon then raced into the red zone before Taylor brought him down.
“I was on the same side as (Matt) Bushman, who is a really great tight end, so a lot of eyes and a lot of guys were looking at him,” Simon said. “I think they just kind of had a mis-lapse in coverage and I got behind the guys and Zach made a great pass.”
After Wilson spiked the ball with five seconds left, Jake Oldroyd kicked his third field goal, a 33-yarder that barely slipped inside the right upright with a second remaining.
The Cougars got the ball first in overtime and scored on Wilson’s 14-yard touchdown pass to Talon Shumway. Tennessee tied it on Jarrett Guarantano’s 13-yard pass to Jennings.
Tennessee opened the second overtime session by settling for Brent Cimaglia’s fourth field goal, a 40-yarder that briefly gave the Vols a 26-23 lead.
Then Williams ended it once and for all.
The South Carolina graduate transfer appeared to be stopped just a few yards short of the end zone on second-and-3 from the 5, but he kept running until he crossed the goal line. His offensive linemen pushed him along those last couple of yards.
“I just got in there and just got dirty, just kept my feet moving and was able to get to the goal line and score a touchdown,” said Williams, who ran for 92 yards and two scores.
Wilson finished 19-of-29 passing for 232 yards. Guarantano threw for 97 yards in the first quarter but just 79 yards the rest of the way, and his interception early in the second half set up a BYU touchdown.
Tennessee scored a touchdown off a deflected pass on its opening drive when it went for it on fourth-and-3 from the 5, but the Vols failed to capitalize on plenty of other scoring chances.
They lost the ball on downs at the BYU 19 and at the BYU 30, and they settled for four field goals.
Those missed opportunities eventually cost them the game.
“The bottom line is there’s a couple of errors we made in the game that you can’t do,” Tennessee coach Jeremy Pruitt said. “You can’t do. You just don’t do. It’s tough to win against anybody when you make errors like that.
“It’s a tough pill for everybody to swallow. Everybody worked hard this week, responded the right way.”
Tennessee hosts Football Championship Subdivision program Chattanooga on Saturday.